In a significant decision, the Federal Court has found full-time FIFO electricians working a 21 days on/7 days off roster at a West Australian magnetite mine do not accrue paid leave during their off-swing.
The arguments
SIMPEC, which was contracted to provide works at Fortescue’s Iron Bridge Project near Port Headland, calculated leave entitlements on the basis that 114 ordinary hours were worked during each on-swing (38 ordinary hours for each week) and unpaid authorised leave was given for 38 ordinary hours during each off-swing.

Hours above 114 ordinary hours during the on-swing were paid at overtime rates.
The roster was such that the total hours worked were well above 152 hours each on-swing (being the total ordinary hours for a full-time employee working a regular five-day working week plus overtime over a four week period).
SIMPEC’s position was that because the off-swing week was taken as “unpaid authorised leave”, the ordinary hours for the leave period did not count towards the accrual of annual and personal leave.
Further, as the employees were paid overtime for each hour after 38 hours in an on-swing week, they had been properly remunerated.
However, in bringing proceedings against SIMPEC, the Electrical Trades Union (ETU) argued the workers had not been afforded their full leave entitlements.
It said that under a proper interpretation of the EA, the workers accrued annual leave and personal leave entitlements based upon ordinary hours worked of 152 hours for each swing.
The basis for this claim was the 21 days on, 7 days off roster compressed four weeks of ordinary hours for a full-time employee into the three weeks of the on-swing.
As the workers were full-time, the union contended they were entitled to the same annual leave and personal leave they would have accrued if they had worked the regular hours provided for in the EA (accruing 152 ordinary hours for each four weeks of full-time employment).
The union sought compensation and interest to be paid to the workers.
Decision
Justice Craig Colvin observed the ETU’s “difficulty” was that the EA did not permit the allocation of 152 ordinary hours in the 21 day on-swing, pointing to a “further issue that would arise concerning overtime calculations because, in effect, it seeks to have the same hours counted both as ordinary hours and overtime hours”.
He said the Agreement’s Rest and Recreation Leave provision (clause 12) was at the heart of the dispute:
12.1 An Employee may be required to work a system of works that includes Rest and Recreation Leave (R&R). R&R usually consists of a period of unpaid authorised leave, accrued RDOs (if applicable) and any paid leave which has been requested and approved.
Justice Colvin explained:
“By the express terms of cl 12, full-time employees were not entitled to any payment for the days they were rostered off where those days were to be treated as unpaid authorised leave.
“Consequently, by the end of a year, full-time employees working the 21 days on-swing, 7 days off-swing roster would not accrue a year’s leave entitlements under the NES provisions because they would not have completed a period of employment of 12 months. Every fourth week of their continuous service would not be counted under the NES provisions because the unpaid authorised leave in respect of ordinary hours that was allowed by cl 12 would not count towards the accrual of annual leave and personal leave.”
He said SIMPEC had claimed clause 12 provided for flexibility in rostering, operating in a way that reduced the annual and personal leave entitlements of full-time employees which would otherwise arise on the express terms of the EA.
“SIMPEC’s case is that it could deploy cl 12 to specify a system of works which would mean that full-time employees would not be able to earn the leave entitlements that would otherwise be earned by a full-time employee. Instead, they would accrue the same annual leave and personal leave entitlements of part-time employees who were working just 75% of the ordinary hours of a full-time employee (or, on SIMPEC’s alternative case, they could be required to work many additional hours above 38 ordinary hours per week without overtime). Further, all this was possible without any terms of the EA expressly exposing that consequence to the employees.”
Justice Colvin said the off-setting benefit was that for the system of works to comply with the EA, employees were paid for many more hours at overtime rates than if they had worked the ordinary hours under the EA.
“In a sense, the consequence of the roster is that there were less paid ordinary hours than were contemplated for a full-time employee and the accrual of three-quarters of the leave entitlements of a person who was paid for all those ordinary hours,” Justice Colvin said.
“However, that part of the union’s case fails to allow for the operation of cl 12 and the fact that the leave entitlements were sourced in the NES, not the EA.
“The system of works did not result in less ordinary hours. Rather, the system of works meant that 38 ordinary hours of each four-week swing were required to be taken as unpaid authorised leave.
“This was a course expressly authorised by the EA. Its consequence for the operation of the NES leave provisions was a statutory outcome.”
Justice Colvin dismissed the application.
Employer implications
AREEA welcomes this as a good decision that reinforces common practice across the resources industry.
The union was seeking a windfall gain in this matter. It sought to have the same hours counted both as ordinary hours and overtime hours.
If the union’s case was accepted, the employees would effectively “double dip” by being paid at overtime for the 38 additional hours worked on top of their ordinary hours within their 21-day roster, while also accruing paid leave entitlements for those overtime hours.
Under the Fair Work Act, an employee may be required to work a system of work that includes Rest and Recreation Leave under the EA. In this case, employees work a 21-day-on and 7-day-off roster. R&R consists of a period of 7 unpaid days of authorised leave.
The ordinary hours in the off-swing week are taken as unpaid authorised leave and in determining the NES annual leave and personal leave entitlements, those hours do not count.
Because of the roster, employees are paid less ordinary hours (114 hours) than are contemplated for full-time employees (152 hours) and the accrual of three-quarters of the leave entitlements of a person who is paid for 152 ordinary hours. The quid pro quo is the employees receive a guaranteed 38 hours of overtime within each roster cycle.
In addition to confirming employers can implement bespoke roster arrangements such as the above, the decision also reinforces the cruciality of careful enterprise agreement drafting.
For assistance and advice on drafting EA terms to achieve organisational goals and minimise ambiguities and risk, contact AREEA’s expert Workplace Advisory team.